Liberte up in flames

May 3, 2021


Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , ,

first_imgCar on burning car symbolises the razing of French democracy to the ground, as violence flares across the republic. Last weekend saw the introduction of curfews by city authorities as part of the emergency legislation implemented by the French government. The fifty year old law was originally brought in as an attempt to counteract the guerrilla efforts during the algerian war of independence, but, as of last week, is now being used for the first time in mainland France.later, the British summer became unusually hot when the northern towns of Oldham, Bradford and Burnley were set ablaze after alleged provocation by the British National Front-inspired race riots.As well as allowing local authorities to put curfews into place, it has some potentially far more unsettling features. Measures can be imposed upon the whole country, restricting people’s movements in even completely unaffected areas. authorities have the power to assume control of the media. police are free to carry out raids on homes as they deem necessary. The latter was intended to act upon suspicion of stockpiling weapons, but is currently in use to freely search for suspected participants in the violence. it is now illegal to meet publicly with the perceived intention of causing disorder. This in practice could mean as little as peaceful protest.Firm and swift action may be needed, but the suspension of civil liberties may go unquestioned by parliament for up to twelve days. democracy is on hold. it is not without irony that France, which still prides itself on its revolutionary principles of liberté, égalité and fraternité and annually celebrates the storming of the Bastille, can dismiss liberté so quickly and show little concern towards the effects such action will have on any remaining sense of fraternité. admittedly, this violence seems to lack political purpose, but the revolution too was first and foremost an uprising against inequality. Britain, at least, seems more consistent. On 5 November, the majority of the population celebrated, once again, the prevention of an attack upon our democracy. in doing so, we ritualistically burned an effigy of our most notorious terrorist to the sound of shouts and cheers. keeping with such aggressive tradition, our government is responding to the risk of terrorism with excessive legislation. while for us fire and explosions mark the preservation of democracy, for France it marks its suspension.The first of the riots took place on the evening of 27 October in clichy-sous-Bois following the deaths of two boys. The teenagers had run into an electricity substation under the assumption that they were being chased by police after being found at the scene of a break-in. authorities have since denied this. Nevertheless, the belief spread that the police were to blame, helped by the silent march which took place two days later where marchers wore tops emblazoned with the slogan ‘dead for nothing’.Regardless of the specifics, the fuel for the fire has been mounting for a long time. Many of the post-war immigrants have never fully integrated into society and since the 1980s the hLMs (habitations à Loyer Modéré), state-provided accommodation, home to large groups from ethnic minorities, have become symbols of social exclusion. Visible monuments to separation between the inhabitants of the cités and the rest of society have also purportedly become the source of discrimination in job application. For years, stories have circulated of employers at interview, on sight of the address on the head of the form, informing applicants from HLMs that the position has already been filled. whether completely true or not, there are undoubtedly still racial tensions in the banlieues of cities throughout France. it could be argued that class provides the greatest social divisions, but the importance of cultural differences must not be ignored either. skin colour or religious symbolism, such as a headscarf, merely supplies a visual stimulus with which to pigeonhole people, typically as criminals and never victims.Hence, it was not with applause that the unsympathetic comments made on 25 October, two days prior to the first troubles, by interior Minister, Nicolas sarkozy, were met. His suggestion to take a “power hose” to areas with high crime was both insensitive and incendiary. after all, it has been his decision to substantially reduce the number of community police officers, only for them to have to return charging in full riot gear.Even François Massenet, secretary general of uNsa-police, the union for French expressed malaise over sarkozy’s comments, which he implied was a part-timer’s response. Too often have the French government responded to situations on a short-term, reactionist basis, rather than considering long-term plans for such enormous problems. But what democratic government is not guilty of the same?Riots are, of course, nothing new. in 1991 the beating of the african-american rodney King sparked race riots in Los angeles. Ten years Indeed, the recent violence has been compared to the events of May 1968, which spread throughout the population gaining support from all demographics. The increasing unrest over the last couple of weeks is, unlike the student revolts, unlikely to spread from its current lone demographic. while people of the same social class and ethnic background may show solidarity in not condemning the random acts of violence, there can be no such support in other areas of society, when it lacks a political or ideological focus. On the contrary, the acts have been solely an expression of anger. There is little political motivation behind beating elderly men to death or setting disabled women alight, although these are only isolated incidents and the far-right have been also been active attempting to incite further divisions along racial fault lines.There are uncanny parallels between the very real and very awful events of the previous weeks and the fictional ones of La haine. in Mathieu Kassovitz’s 1995 film, a boy dies after sustaining injuries while in police custody. rioting ensues and, ultimately, Vinz, the young Jewish protagonist, seeks his own retribution for the injustice. his anger, or hate, appears slightly self-indulgent, but is, symbolically, uncontrollable and indiscriminate; he does not seem to care who he hurts, employing an us-against-them mentality. The consequences are bloody and tragic. Police react with extreme force.Of course, a policeman’s job in such a situation is of inestimable difficulty and the fictional police are portrayed rather unsympathetically. It has, nevertheless, been alleged that police officers have referred to suspects as “dirty arabs” and told families of children thought to be involved in the violence, in their own homes, to “go home”. This just goes to show what bubbles under the surface, even when tensions are not so high.So, while it remains difficult to discern protest from wanton destruction and aggression, which would seem to support the actions of the French administration, handing over more power to the police is not necessarily a sensible idea. The allegations against police, even if untrue, present more provocation. As one youth is quoted by Le parisien as saying, “More repression means more destruction.”Immigrants who would once have been proud of their individual heritage now often refer to themselves just as Muslims, adopting religion, a potential source of radicalism, as the part of them that binds them with the largest number of people. Feelings of social isolation and hopelessness may lead some to extreme measures, partly because it creates an unbreakable solidarity between themselves and others like them.Media groups fail to agree on whether, as the Le Figaro reports, “tous se disent solidaires des violences urbaines de ces derniers jours” (‘everyone claims solidarity with the instances of urban violence in recent days’) or whether in fact, as patrick Sabatir of Libération stated, “most inhabitants of these ghettos do not approve of their [those involved] senseless destruction”. continued to claim that, since there is no political motivation behind the actions of youths, the violence is purely “blind rage against injustice and inequality”.When even French rappers, such as the social lyricist, shurik’N, disseminate awareness of the ever-present aggression within the cités, it beggars belief that the government are yet to act for the long-term. Not that it is likely that dominique de Villepin listens to rap music in between cabinet meetings, but this fact is, nonetheless, demonstrative of the administration’s ignorance of or, worse still, insensibility to the burgeoning social conflicts in their own country. in fact, it is completely deaf to such problems, as it collects no information about issues such as academic success or failure of distinct social or ethnic groups under the impression that they are preserving égalité. as such, it is impossible to know the full extent of the current divides between social groups and so even more difficult to solve them.Quite simply, the government have, for whatever reason, failed to move for preventative, or at least containing, actions. This is surely a fault of government. They have surely let down the people who they represent. Yet, this is sadly not the case. democracy, far from representing the people, represents only those who elect the government or, in fact, only those who will vote for them next time. with this in mind, long-term plans are rarely implemented. Moreover, social divides are maintained, as some groups will always be neglected by an elected government. even a Labour government, albeit a New Labour government, has increased the gap between rich and poor.So, while we might bandy about the idea of democracy as the route to social freedom, even invade a country or two on our crusade of ideals, let us stop for a moment, perhaps longer, and reflect on the limitations of the system we share with the rest of the western world. Of course, enjoy your personal freedoms, while the wheels of democracy still turn, but appreciate that they are driven by someone else, who can stamp on the brakes at any moment.ARCHIVE: 6th week MT 2005last_img read more

Men’s soccer pushes past Penn

March 1, 2021


Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , ,

first_img Passing through Andre Akpan ’10 moves swiftly down the field toward a Penn defender. The impenetrable wall A diving Austin Harms ’12 makes one of two key saves on the day, earning his sixth shutout of the year in Harvard’s 1-0 victory over Penn. Jon Chase/Harvard Staff Photographer Needing one win to claim the Ancient Eight crown and an automatic NCAA playoff berth, freshman defender Richard Smith came up big for the Harvard men’s soccer team against Penn on Nov. 15, netting the game’s only goal in the 68th minute to put the Crimson up, 1-0.From there, tight defensive play for Harvard was enough to hold off the Quakers, as the Crimson clinched their first Ivy League championship since 2006 (13th overall) and finished the regular season with the team’s best record in more than a decade. Quality control Crimson midfielder Robert Millock ’11 controls the ball in front of a Penn player. Running toward the rock In a mad dash for the ball, Harvard midfielder Desmond Mitchell ’10 is too fast for his Penn counterpart. The victors Erupting in cheers, the Harvard men’s soccer team celebrates a hard-earned Ivy League Championship. Harvard vs. Penn Put it on the board Two-time Ivy Rookie of the Week Brian Rogers ’13 celebrates after teammate Richard Smith ’13 scores the game’s only goal. Making necessary headway Crimson midfielder Adam Rousmaniere ’10 tries to put a head on the ball while fending off a defender. Bringing ‘Ivy’ back to Cambridge Baba Omosegbon ’12 (left) and Andre Akpan ’10 share a joyful moment at game’s end. Flight 006 clearing for takeoff Baba Omosegbon ’12 leaps over a fallen Penn player in pursuit of the ball. Sophomore goalkeeper Austin Harms made two saves in posting his sixth shutout of the season. Smith’s game-winning tally was his first career goal, and earned him Ivy League Rookie of the Week honors.The Crimson finished the regular season ranked 11th nationally with a record of 13-3-1 (5-1-1 Ivy League). Harvard, who has a first round bye in the NCAA tournament, will host the winner of Friday’s (Nov. 20) Monmouth or Connecticut match. Game time is set for Sunday (Nov. 22, 1 p.m.) at Ohiri Field.last_img read more

Hughes hoping for more home help

September 20, 2020


Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , ,

first_imgMark Hughes hopes Stoke’s fans can help them get back on track when Arsenal visit the Britannia Stadium on Saturday. Potters fans enjoy nothing more than beating Arsenal and always give Gunners manager Arsene Wenger – a critic of their style of play under previous boss Tony Pulis – a ‘warm’ welcome. The rowdy atmosphere has inspired Stoke in recent matches against Arsenal, with the Potters losing just one of the last eight clashes between the teams at the Britannia. Keeping that run going would be particularly timely as Hughes’ team look to end a run of three straight defeats. “This fixture always seems to generate a really good atmosphere,” said the Stoke boss. “It started before my time I would suggest. It’s an incredible atmosphere inside the stadium for matches like this and it takes a good team to deal with it. “For the most part Arsenal are an outstanding team but in recent times we’ve done very well. The help we’ve had from our crowd has been part of that. It’s a huge part when you’re trying to get positive results. I enjoy coming up against them and I am sure the lads do, too. “We are performing well at the moment – we just aren’t converting our chances when they come along. From my experience in the game, these runs can’t keep on going. “If we play as well as we have done recently then we will soon start to win matches in a convincing manner, I am certain of that.” Hughes has plenty of injury problems to deal with but is hoping one or two players could be back, with Jonathan Walters and Robert Huth the most likely contenders. “It is undoubtedly the worst run of injuries that I have had during my time at the club and, when you consider the fact that we have had a bout of illness going around the place too, we have been unfortunate,” said Hughes. “Stephen Ireland has picked a bit of illness up disappointingly, because we thought we had seen the last of that.” Wenger is confident his side can cope with whatever awaits them at Stoke, but could do without “exaggerated” pre-match comments aimed at turning up the heat. Stoke captain Ryan Shawcross – whose horror tackle on Aaron Ramsey in 2010 left the Gunners’ midfielder with a double leg break – claims the home fans “dislike” of Arsenal will lead to a “tasty game” at the Britannia Stadium. Wenger – who once labelled Stoke’s tactics under Pulis as “rugby on the goalkeepers” – believes his side must concentrate on their own game rather than worry about what they might face both on and off the pitch. “I think that is exaggerated. It is a football game, it is not a hate game. You want to focus on playing football,” said Wenger, whose side have just one win at Stoke from seven matches since 2008. “Stoke is always a tough and very committed place to go, but we prepare ourselves to be at the level of our commitment and dictate the way we want to play. The most important thing is to not forget how we play our game. “They have a little bit of a different style (under new manager Hughes), but against us it is always a very committed game anyway.” Wenger added: “We are in a job where you have risks. The physical risk is part of our job, we accept that. “What you want is to go into a game with everybody being 100 per cent committed, but fair. After, you accept that any accident can happen. “You do not want to have any suspicions before the match starts, that is not very good.” Arsenal have some defensive worries, with Nacho Monreal having suffered ankle ligament damage early on against the Saints, and so could be out for a few weeks. Centre-back Laurent Koscielny will be assessed on his inflamed Achilles. Full-back Mathieu Debuchy is close to a return from three months recovery from an ankle injury, and may be taken to Istanbul for next week’s Champions League tie at Galatasaray. Press Associationlast_img read more